Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) has announced a vote to confirm Pete Hegseth as Secretary of Defense under President Donald Trump, despite allegations outlined in a recent affidavit from Hegseth’s former sister-in-law. A former Fox News host and Army veteran, Hegseth has faced mounting criticism over claims of alcohol abuse and alleged abusive behavior, casting a shadow over his qualifications for leading the Department of Defense.
The nomination narrowly advanced in the Senate Armed Services Committee, with a party-line vote of 14-13, setting the stage for a high-stakes confirmation battle in the Senate.
Allegations Surface Amid Confirmation Process
The controversy stems from an affidavit submitted by Hegseth’s former sister-in-law, who alleged that he struggled with excessive alcohol consumption and engaged in abusive behavior toward his ex-wife, Samantha Hegseth. Among the claims, the affidavit details an incident in which Samantha reportedly sought refuge in a closet out of fear for her safety.
However, Samantha Hegseth has publicly denied the allegations of physical abuse. In a statement issued Tuesday, she clarified, “There was no physical abuse during our marriage.”
Despite Samantha’s denial, Senate Democrats, led by Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), have called the affidavit a credible and serious concern. “These firsthand accounts raise substantial questions about Pete Hegseth’s character and readiness to lead the Department of Defense,” Blumenthal said. “There is no doubt he is unqualified and unprepared to serve in this critical position.”
Republican Defense of Hegseth
Republican leaders have largely dismissed the allegations. Senate Armed Services Committee Chair Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) expressed skepticism about the affidavit’s validity, noting Samantha Hegseth’s public denial. “I have serious doubts regarding its validity,” Wicker told reporters. “I believe the nomination will proceed.”
Prominent GOP Senator Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), a retired Air Force lawyer with influence on national security matters, also downplayed the claims. “I heard what his wife stated. It did not occur,” Graham said, adding, “You have the individual who denies any physical abuse. That is sufficient for me.”
Graham further dismissed accusations of alcohol abuse, reaffirming his support for Hegseth.
Democratic Concerns and Procedural Delays
Senate Democrats remain united in their opposition to Hegseth’s nomination, with some attempting to delay the final confirmation vote. Senator Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) criticized Republicans for rushing the process, drawing comparisons to the GOP’s treatment of nominees under President Joe Biden.
“It is ironic that Republicans obstructed numerous national security nominees during President Biden’s term and are now complaining when we request two days of discussion for one of Trump’s key national security appointees,” Murphy said.
Murphy’s comments reflect broader Democratic concerns about the implications of confirming Hegseth without thorough vetting. “This is about the integrity of our national security leadership,” Murphy added.
Confirmation Timeline
Senate Majority Leader John Thune filed a motion on Tuesday to conclude debate on Hegseth’s nomination, setting up a procedural cloture vote for Thursday. If the motion passes, a final confirmation vote is expected late Friday or early Saturday morning.
Senate Republicans are confident in their ability to secure the votes needed for confirmation. “The next step will be on cloture, scheduled for Thursday afternoon,” Wicker said.
Meanwhile, the Senate must also address the nomination of former Representative John Ratcliffe (R-Texas) to serve as CIA director. Ratcliffe’s confirmation, initially scheduled for Tuesday, was delayed by Democratic opposition, with Senator Murphy emphasizing the need for extended debate.
A Polarized Senate
The debate over Pete Hegseth’s nomination underscores the deep partisan divide in Washington. For Republicans, Hegseth’s military service and media career make him a strong candidate to lead the Pentagon. For Democrats, the allegations against him and questions about his temperament and judgment raise red flags about his ability to manage the complexities of national defense.
As the Senate prepares for final votes, the outcome will likely hinge on party-line divisions, reflecting the broader polarization that has come to define modern U.S. politics.
