The passing of Jimmy Carter, the 39th President of the United States, marked the end of an era. At 100 years old, Carter held the distinction of being the longest-living former president in U.S. history. On January 9, 2025, a memorial service was held at the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., honoring his remarkable life and legacy.
Among the tributes, a performance by country music icons Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood drew significant attention and, unexpectedly, controversy. While the duo intended to pay their respects to Carter with a heartfelt rendition of John Lennon’s classic, Imagine, the song choice stirred debate among attendees and viewers alike.
A Tribute to a Lifelong Friend
Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood shared a deep connection with Jimmy Carter. Over the years, they had collaborated with him on numerous humanitarian efforts, including Habitat for Humanity, a cause Carter championed throughout his life. Their performance at the memorial was meant to honor not just a president but a personal friend whose values and vision they admired deeply.
The decision to perform Imagine stemmed from Carter’s personal fondness for the song. In interviews, Carter had expressed his admiration for Lennon’s masterpiece, calling it one of his all-time favorites. He once described how the song’s themes of peace, unity, and hope resonated with him, particularly during his travels to places like Cuba, where Imagine held almost anthem-like status.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749x0:751x2):format(webp)/garth-brooks-trisha-yearwood-jimmy-carter-funeral-010925-2-ab39c29c35d842a4a8e0c4ee5accd120.jpg)
Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood perform at former President Jimmy Carter’s funeral in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 9, 2025. Photo:
NBC News/YouTube
The Song Choice Sparks a Backlash
Despite the personal significance of the song to Carter, its inclusion in a Christian funeral service raised eyebrows. Imagine, widely regarded as a universal anthem of peace, includes lyrics that challenge traditional religious beliefs:
“Imagine there’s no heaven,
It’s easy if you try,
No hell below us,
Above us only sky.”
For some, these lyrics clashed with the setting of the National Cathedral, a historic place of worship, and the deeply Christian faith that Carter held.
Social media quickly became a platform for debate. Critics questioned the appropriateness of performing a song that seemingly rejects religion at a Christian funeral.
One commenter expressed their shock:
“Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood sing Imagine at a highly Christian funeral? Imagine there’s no Heaven? That’s incredibly tone-deaf.”
Another echoed the sentiment, writing:
“Jimmy Carter was a devout Christian. Singing Imagine at his funeral feels disrespectful. It’s a beautiful song, but not for this context.”
The Power of Context
While the performance faced criticism, some fans defended the choice. They highlighted Carter’s personal connection to the song and its broader themes of unity and hope, values that defined his presidency and post-political life.
One supporter noted:
“Carter loved Imagine. It represented his vision of a peaceful world. Brooks and Yearwood honored his legacy beautifully.”
Another viewer praised the performance:
“It was one of the most moving tributes I’ve ever seen. Garth and Trisha brought so much emotion to it.”
The mixed reactions underscore the challenges of balancing personal tributes with broader public expectations, particularly in highly symbolic settings like a state funeral.
Carter’s Enduring Vision
For Carter, Imagine was more than a song. It symbolized a worldview that championed global unity, empathy, and the breaking down of barriers—whether national, religious, or cultural. He often spoke about the song’s ability to inspire hope and foster understanding among people from diverse backgrounds.
In reflecting on Lennon’s lyrics, Carter once remarked that the song’s critique of religion and nationalism was less about rejection and more about envisioning a world where these constructs didn’t divide humanity. This perspective aligned with his lifelong dedication to diplomacy, human rights, and community service.
A Tribute to Remember
Regardless of the controversy, Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood’s performance succeeded in sparking conversation—a fitting tribute to a president who often challenged norms and encouraged dialogue.
Their rendition of Imagine wasn’t just a performance; it was a reflection of Jimmy Carter’s enduring legacy. For some, it was a poignant reminder of his values. For others, it highlighted the complexities of interpreting those values in a public and deeply symbolic event.
As the nation remembers Jimmy Carter, his influence and ideals continue to inspire. Whether through his work with Habitat for Humanity, his dedication to peace, or his appreciation for a song that called for a better world, Carter’s legacy remains a testament to a life well-lived.
Morgan White is the Lead Writer and Editorial Director at Bengali Media, driving the creation of impactful and engaging content across the website. As the principal author and a visionary leader, Morgan has established himself as the backbone of Bengali Media, contributing extensively to its growth and reputation.
With a degree in Mass Communication from University of Ljubljana and over 6 years of experience in journalism and digital publishing, Morgan is not just a writer but a strategist. His expertise spans news, popular culture, and lifestyle topics, delivering articles that inform, entertain, and resonate with a global audience.
Under his guidance, Bengali Media has flourished, attracting millions of readers and becoming a trusted source of authentic and original content. Morgan’s leadership ensures the team consistently produces high-quality work, maintaining the website’s commitment to excellence.
You can connect with Morgan on LinkedIn at Morgan White/LinkedIn to discover more about his career and insights into the world of digital media.