“Something the clinic should have told both of us forty-two years ago.”
The woman on my doorstep said it with tears running down her face.
I was standing in my front hall in my bathrobe, holding my three-day-old daughter against my chest. It was ten o’clock on a Thursday morning. I hadn’t slept more than two hours at a stretch since we came home from the hospital. There was spit-up on my shoulder. My hair was a mess.
And a stranger was holding out an envelope with my name on it.
I didn’t take it right away.
I stood there in the doorway with Grace’s warm little head tucked under my chin, and I looked at that envelope.
It was old. You could tell from across the threshold. The paper had gone soft and yellow. The corners were rounded off like something that had been carried in a pocket or a purse for a long time. There was a faded logo in the upper left corner.
I knew that logo.
A blue circle with a white tree inside it.
The Hartford Reproductive Medicine Center.
The clinic where I’d had my eggs frozen in 1983.
The same clinic where, eleven months ago, they’d thawed the last one.
Underneath the logo, in blue ink, in somebody’s careful, slanted handwriting, was my name.
Margaret A. Ellison.
“Who are you?” I said.
The woman swallowed.
“My name is Rebecca,” she said. “Rebecca Thorne.”
She looked at Grace again. She couldn’t stop looking at Grace.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I’m so sorry. I know this is—I know you just had a baby. I know I shouldn’t be here. I almost didn’t come. I sat in my car across the street for two hours.”
I looked past her. There was a gray Subaru parked at the curb across the street. Engine off. Driver’s door still open.
“The clinic called me yesterday,” Rebecca said. “After your daughter was born.”
I pulled Grace closer.
“Why would the clinic call you about my daughter?”
Rebecca didn’t answer.
She held the envelope out a little farther. Her hand was shaking.
“I think you need to read this,” she said. “Before I say anything else. I think it should come from them. Not me.”
I didn’t move.
“What is it?” I said.
Her eyes filled up again.
“Something the clinic should have told both of us,” she said. “Forty-two years ago.”
And standing there in my doorway, looking at her face, something cold went through me.
Because I’d been looking at her face for almost a full minute now.
And I’d been looking at it wrong.
I’d been looking at a stranger. A red-eyed, tired, middle-aged woman in a navy peacoat with her dark hair pulled back.
But now I saw her chin.
Square. With a little cleft in it. Like a thumbprint.
My mother’s chin.
My chin.
The chin I’d seen in the mirror every morning for seventy-five years.
Suddenly, the woman on my doorstep didn’t feel like a stranger at all.
My name is Margaret Ellison. I’m seventy-five years old.
I taught high school chemistry at Conard High School in West Hartford, Connecticut, for thirty-eight years. I retired in 2010. I live in the same small brick Cape Cod on Fern Street that I bought in 1981, when I was thirty-one, with a down payment I’d saved for six years.
I’ve never been married.
I’ve never had children.
Until three days ago.
I need to tell you how I got here. Because I know what you’re thinking. I know what everybody thinks.
Seventy-five years old. A newborn. Is she crazy? Is she selfish? Who’s going to raise that child when she dies?
I’ve heard all of it.
From my sister. From my doctor. From the women in my book club. From the young nurse at Hartford Hospital who looked at my chart in the maternity ward, then looked at me, then looked at my chart again.
“Are you the… grandmother?” she said.
“I’m the mother,” I said.
She didn’t know what to say. I didn’t blame her.
I was thirty-three when I froze my eggs.
It was 1983. Nobody did that in 1983. Hardly anybody even knew you could.
The first baby from IVF in America had been born just two years earlier. Elizabeth Carr, in Norfolk, Virginia. It was on the cover of every newspaper. Test tube baby. People were scared of it. Priests wrote angry letters. There were protests.
And egg freezing was even newer. Experimental. A handful of clinics were trying it. Most of the eggs didn’t survive the thaw.
But I’d read about it. In a medical journal at the library at the University of Hartford, where I took night classes for my master’s.
And there was a clinic right there in Hartford that was doing a research program.
I’d been engaged once.
His name was Thomas Avery. He was a lawyer. Tall and funny, with a laugh you could hear across a parking lot. We met at a friend’s Christmas party in 1978. He proposed in 1981, on the Bushnell Park carousel, between the third and fourth time around.
We were going to get married in June of 1982.
In February of 1982, he went skiing in Vermont with his brothers. At Killington. He hit a patch of ice on an expert trail and went into the trees.
He was thirty-four.
I didn’t date for a long time after Thomas.
I threw myself into teaching. Into my students. Into my master’s degree. Into taking care of my mother, whose Parkinson’s was getting worse.
And then, one night in the fall of 1983, sitting in the library, I read that article.
And I thought: I’m thirty-three. I don’t know when I’ll be ready to love somebody again. I don’t know if I ever will be.
But I know I want to be a mother.
So I went to the Hartford Reproductive Medicine Center.
The doctor was a man named Dr. Erik Halvorsen. Mid-forties. Norwegian, originally. Blond going gray, with rimless glasses and a soft, careful voice. He’d trained in London with the team that made the first IVF baby.
He explained everything. The hormone shots, every day for two weeks. The retrieval, under sedation, with a needle. The freezing, which was new and uncertain.
“I have to be honest with you, Miss Ellison,” he said. “This technology is very young. Most frozen eggs don’t survive. You may freeze a dozen and none will ever become a baby.”
“I understand,” I said.
“Then why do it?”
I thought about Thomas. On the carousel. Between the third and fourth time around.
“Because I’d rather have a small chance,” I said, “than none at all.”
I did the shots. Two weeks. In my stomach. Every night at nine o’clock, standing in my kitchen on Fern Street with a syringe and an alcohol swab.
They did the retrieval on a Tuesday in November.
When I woke up, Dr. Halvorsen was standing next to my bed.
“We got eight,” he said. “Eight good eggs. All frozen. All safe.”
Eight.
I held onto that number for forty-two years.
Life happened.
That’s the simplest way to say it.
My mother got sicker. I moved her into my spare bedroom in 1986. I took care of her for nineteen years. Bathed her. Fed her. Turned her at night. She died in 2005, at eighty-eight, holding my hand.
I taught. Thousands of students. I had kids in my classroom who went on to become doctors and engineers and one who won a Nobel Prize in chemistry. I’ve got a picture of him on my refrigerator. He wrote “Thanks, Miss E.” across the bottom.
I dated a few men. Nothing serious. Nothing like Thomas.
I paid the clinic’s storage fee. Every single year. Three hundred dollars in 1984. Eight hundred dollars by 2020. I wrote the check every January. Without fail.
My sister, Joan, thought I was crazy.
“Margaret,” she said, at Thanksgiving in 1999. “You’re forty-nine. What are you going to do with those eggs?”
“I don’t know yet,” I said.
“You’re never going to use them.”
“Maybe not.”
“Then why do you keep paying?”
I didn’t have an answer.
I just kept paying.
At fifty-five, I stopped believing it would happen.
At sixty, I stopped thinking about it.
At sixty-five, after I’d retired, I almost stopped paying the storage fee. I sat at my kitchen table with the bill in front of me and the pen in my hand.
Eight hundred dollars. For eight eggs I was never going to use.
I wrote the check anyway.
Then, two years ago, when I was seventy-three, I had a heart scare.
Atrial fibrillation. My heart started racing one night while I was watching Jeopardy, and it wouldn’t stop. I drove myself to Hartford Hospital at eleven o’clock at night.
They fixed it. A procedure called a cardioversion. They shocked my heart back into rhythm. I was home in two days. On a blood thinner. Told to take it easy.
But lying in that hospital bed, I thought about the eggs.
Eight eggs. In a freezer at the Hartford Reproductive Medicine Center. Waiting.
For forty years.
And I thought: if I die tonight, nobody will ever use them. They’ll just sit there. Until somebody pulls the plug.
I thought: I paid for them for forty years. I believed in them for forty years.
I thought: what if I tried?
I know what you’re thinking.
I thought it too.
Seventy-three years old. A heart condition. How long would I even live? Ten years? Fifteen, if I was lucky? I’d be eighty-five when the child was ten. Ninety when she graduated high school. If I was even alive.
It was selfish. It was irresponsible. It was crazy.
I thought all of that.
And I went to the clinic anyway.
Dr. Halvorsen was long gone, of course. He’d retired in 1998 and died in 2011. A brain tumor.
The clinic had a new director. Dr. Lisa Moreau. Fifties. Sharp. Kind. She’d been there twenty years.
She looked at my file for a long time.
“Miss Ellison,” she said. “I’m going to be very honest with you. Most clinics wouldn’t do this. At your age.”
“I know.”
“You’d need a gestational carrier. A surrogate. You couldn’t carry a pregnancy yourself. It would kill you.”
“I know.”
“And the eggs,” Dr. Moreau said. “They were frozen in 1983. With very early technology. Slow freezing. The survival rates for eggs frozen that way are very low. Maybe ten percent. Maybe less.”
“I know,” I said.
She looked at me.
“Why?” she said. “Why now?”
I thought about it.
I’d been thinking about it for months.
“Because I’ve been a mother my whole life,” I said. “To my students. To my mother, at the end. I’ve taken care of people for fifty years. And I’ve never once had somebody who was mine.”
I looked at my hands on my lap. Old hands. Spotted. Veins showing.
“I know I won’t see her grow up,” I said. “I know that. I’ve made peace with it. But I’d like to hold her. Just for a while. I’d like to know what it feels like.”
Dr. Moreau didn’t say anything for a long time.
“And when you die?” she said. “Who raises her?”
I didn’t have an answer for that.
Not yet.
It took a year.
A year of psychological evaluations. Medical tests. Lawyers. Interviews.
Dr. Moreau made me see a psychiatrist. Three times. The psychiatrist asked me the same questions everybody asked. Why. Why now. Who will raise the child.
I told him I’d named my sister Joan as guardian. She was seventy. She had grandchildren of her own. She said yes, but I could tell she didn’t want to.
I told him I had money. Savings. My pension. My house, paid off. A trust for the child. I’d met with a lawyer in Farmington. Everything in writing.
The psychiatrist wrote it all down. He didn’t approve. But he didn’t say no.
I found a surrogate.
Her name was Jolene Pierce. She was thirty-one. A mother of three. A dental assistant from Manchester. She’d been a surrogate twice before. For two gay couples in Boston.
“I like making families,” she said, at our first meeting. At a Panera in Glastonbury. “My kids came easy. Some people’s don’t.”
She looked at me.
“You’re the oldest one I’ve ever met,” she said. “By a lot.”
“I know.”
“Why’d you wait so long?”
I told her about Thomas. On the carousel. Between the third and fourth time around.
Jolene put her hand over mine on the table.
“Okay,” she said. “Let’s make you a family.”
They thawed the eggs one at a time.
That’s how it works. You don’t thaw all of them at once. You thaw one. You see if it survives. If it does, you fertilize it. With donor sperm. I’d picked a donor from a catalog. A music teacher from Oregon with brown hair and a good heart, according to his profile.
You see if it grows into an embryo. If it does, you transfer it into the surrogate. You wait two weeks.
If it doesn’t work, you thaw the next one.
The first egg didn’t survive the thaw.
The second one did. It fertilized. It started to grow. Then it stopped on day three.
The third one didn’t survive.
The fourth survived. It grew. They transferred it into Jolene in April. We waited two weeks.
Negative.
The fifth didn’t survive.
The sixth didn’t survive.
The seventh survived. It grew to day five. A blastocyst, they called it. They transferred it in June.
Two weeks later, Jolene called me from her car in the parking lot of the dental office where she worked.
“Margaret,” she said. She was crying. “Margaret. It’s positive.”
It was positive for nine days.
On the tenth day, Jolene started bleeding.
I drove to the clinic. I sat in the waiting room for three hours.
Dr. Moreau came out. She sat down next to me. She didn’t have to say anything.
I knew.
There was one left.
One egg. The eighth. The last.
Dr. Moreau sat with me in her office afterward.
“Margaret,” she said. “I want you to think about this very carefully. You’ve been through a lot. Seven eggs. Two transfers. One loss. This is the last one.”
“I know.”
“If it doesn’t work,” she said, “that’s it. There won’t be any more.”
“I know, Lisa.”
She looked at me for a long time.
“Do you want to try?”
I went home.
I sat at my kitchen table on Fern Street. Where I’d given myself those shots in 1983.
I thought about Thomas.
I thought about my mother, in the spare bedroom, holding my hand when she died.
I thought about Jolene in her car in the parking lot, crying.
I thought about the eighth egg, sitting in a freezer for forty-one years.
Then I picked up the phone.
“Lisa,” I said. “Let’s try.”
The eighth egg survived the thaw.
It fertilized.
It grew. Day one. Day two. Day three. Day four. Day five.
They transferred it into Jolene in September.
Two weeks later, she called me from the dental office parking lot again.
“Positive,” she said.
I didn’t let myself believe it.
Not at six weeks, when they heard the heartbeat.
Not at twelve weeks, when they did the first big ultrasound and I saw a tiny shape on the screen, waving its arms.
Not at twenty weeks, when they told us it was a girl.
I didn’t let myself believe it until the day Jolene went into labor.
Grace was born on a Monday in June.
At Hartford Hospital. At 3:47 in the morning. Seven pounds, two ounces. Twenty inches long. A full head of dark hair.
Jolene’s husband, Ray, held one of Jolene’s hands. I held the other.
When the doctor held her up, she was screaming. Purple and furious and slick. Waving her fists.
The nurse cleaned her off and wrapped her in a white blanket with blue and pink stripes.
And she turned around and looked at me.
“Who’s taking her?” she said.
I held out my arms.
My old arms. Spotted. Veins showing. Seventy-five years old.
The nurse put my daughter in them.
She was perfect.
Tiny. Warm. Heavy, in a way I wasn’t expecting. Real.
She stopped screaming.
She opened her eyes. Dark blue, the way they are at first. Unfocused. Looking at nothing. Looking at everything.
Looking at me.
I couldn’t stop crying.
Jolene was crying. Ray was crying. Even the doctor’s eyes were wet.
“Hello, Grace,” I said. “Hello, my darling. I’m your mother.”
After forty-two years of waiting, I was finally somebody’s mother.
I brought her home three days later.
Joan drove us. My sister. Seventy years old. Gripping the steering wheel of her Buick like it might bite her.
Joan had come around. Slowly. Over the nine months. She’d knitted a blanket. Pale yellow. She’d bought a car seat. She’d helped me paint the spare bedroom. The one where our mother died. A soft green now. With white clouds stenciled on the ceiling.
“I still think you’re crazy,” Joan said. In the car. Looking at Grace in the rearview mirror. “I want you to know that.”
“I know.”
“Absolutely crazy.”
“I know, Joanie.”
Joan looked at the baby in the mirror for a long time.
“She has Mother’s nose,” she said quietly.
The first three days at home were a blur.
I’d forgotten how much a baby needs. Every two hours. Feeding. Burping. Changing. Rocking. Feeding again.
I was seventy-five. My back hurt. My knees hurt. My heart did a funny little skip once, on the second night, and I had to sit down on the edge of the bed and breathe until it stopped.
I didn’t care.
I sat in the rocking chair in the green room at three in the morning with Grace asleep on my chest, and I looked up at the clouds on the ceiling, and I was happier than I’d ever been in my life.
And then, on Thursday morning, there was a knock at the door.
I took the envelope.
I don’t know why. Something about her face. About her chin.
I shifted Grace to my left shoulder. I took the envelope in my right hand.
“Come in,” I said.
She came in.
She stood in my front hall. In her navy peacoat. Looking around. At the coat rack. At the stairs. At the framed photographs on the wall. My parents’ wedding picture. Me at my college graduation. Thomas and me on the carousel in Bushnell Park, 1981, laughing.
She stopped in front of that one.
She looked at it for a long time.
“Is that you?” she said.
“Yes.”
“How old were you?”
“Thirty-one.”
She turned and looked at me.
I watched her look at my face. At my chin. At the cleft.
She touched her own chin.
Her hand was shaking.
“Sit down,” I said. “Please. In the kitchen.”
She sat at my kitchen table.
I sat across from her. With Grace asleep on my shoulder.
I put the envelope on the table between us.
I looked at it for a long time.
Then I opened it.
Inside was a letter.
Two pages. Typed, on clinic letterhead. With the blue circle and the white tree at the top. Dated March 4, 1984.
And signed, at the bottom of the second page, in that same careful, slanted handwriting.
Erik Halvorsen, M.D.
Dear Miss Ellison,
I am writing this letter because I have done something I cannot undo, and I do not have the courage to tell you in person.
I will place this letter in your file. I will also place a copy with the recipient family, with instructions that it be given to you if the child ever wishes to know her origins. I do not know if you will ever read it. I suspect you will not. I suspect I am writing it more for myself than for you.
On November 15, 1983, we retrieved fourteen eggs from you. Not eight. Fourteen.
I stopped reading.
I looked up.
Rebecca was watching me. Her hands were folded on the table. She wasn’t crying anymore. She was just watching.
I looked back down.
I froze eight of them, as you requested. The other six I did not freeze.
That same morning, in the room next to yours, I had a patient named Diane Thorne. She was thirty-eight. She and her husband had been trying to conceive for eleven years. Her own eggs were no longer viable. She had come to me as her last hope.
I had no donor eggs. Egg donation was almost unheard of. There were no programs, no donors, no rules.
And in the next room, I had a healthy thirty-three-year-old woman with fourteen eggs.
I told myself you would never use more than eight. I told myself the freezing was so uncertain that the extra six would likely be wasted. I told myself Mrs. Thorne had suffered enough. I told myself a great many things.
I gave six of your eggs to Diane Thorne. Without your knowledge. Without your consent. I fertilized them with her husband’s sperm and transferred two embryos into her uterus that afternoon.
One of them implanted.
Mrs. Thorne is now twenty-six weeks pregnant. With a girl.
Your daughter.
The kitchen was very quiet.
Grace made a little sound on my shoulder. A sigh. She shifted. She settled.
I couldn’t breathe.
I told Mrs. Thorne the eggs came from an anonymous donor. A young woman who wanted to help. She believes that. She is grateful. She calls you her angel.
I have destroyed the records that would connect you. Except for this letter. And the one copy I will give the Thornes, sealed, for the child.
I know what I have done. I have taken something from you that was not mine to take. I have made you a mother without your knowing. I have made a child who will never know her mother.
I could lose my license. I could go to prison. I deserve both.
I am a coward, and I will not confess. But I could not let it remain entirely unwritten.
If you are reading this, I am sorry. I am so very sorry. And if your daughter is reading it with you, I am sorry to her too.
Her name, I am told, will be Rebecca.
— E.H.
I put the letter down.
I looked at the woman sitting across from me at my kitchen table.
Forty-two years old. Navy peacoat. Dark hair pulled back. Red eyes.
My mother’s chin.
My chin.
“Rebecca,” I said.
She nodded.
She couldn’t talk.
She put her hand over her mouth and nodded.
I don’t remember what happened next.
Not exactly.
I remember standing up. I remember Grace waking up and starting to cry. I remember Rebecca standing up too.
I remember the kitchen table between us.
I remember that neither of us moved around it for a long time.
“I’m sorry,” Rebecca said finally. “I’m so sorry. I know you just had a baby. I know this is the worst possible time. I know I shouldn’t have—”
“How long have you known?” I said.
My voice came out strange. Thin. Like it was coming from somebody else.
Rebecca sat back down.
Slowly.
“My mother died in January,” she said. “Diane. Pancreatic cancer. She was seventy-nine.”
She looked down at her hands.
“I was going through her things,” she said. “In her house in Wethersfield. Her closet. Her dresser. And in the bottom drawer, under her sweaters, there was a shoebox. And in the shoebox there were my baby pictures. And my hospital bracelet. And my first tooth. And this.”
She touched the envelope on the table.
“It was sealed,” she said. “It still had Dr. Halvorsen’s note taped to the front. For Rebecca, if she ever wants to know.”
She looked up at me.
“I didn’t open it for a month,” she said. “I didn’t know what it was. I knew I was IVF. My parents told me that when I was ten. They told me I was a miracle. They told me the doctor gave them a gift from an angel. That’s what they called it. An angel.”
She laughed. A broken little laugh.
“I never once thought about who the angel was,” she said. “Not once in forty-two years. I thought it was just a thing people said.”
“In February,” she said, “I opened it.”
She looked at me.
“And it wasn’t addressed to me,” she said. “It was addressed to you. Margaret A. Ellison.”
“I called the clinic,” Rebecca said. “The next morning. I said, I have this letter, I need to find this woman. They wouldn’t tell me anything. Privacy laws. They said they couldn’t confirm or deny that you’d ever been a patient.”
She wiped her eyes.
“I called every Margaret Ellison in Connecticut,” she said. “There are eleven. I called all of them. One of them was a Margaret Ellison in Stamford who was twenty-six. One of them was in a nursing home and didn’t know what year it was.”
“I don’t have a listed number,” I said.
“I know,” Rebecca said. “I found that out. I found your address in March. On a property tax record. Fern Street. I drove by. Twice. I saw you in the yard once. In April. Planting tomatoes.”
She looked at me.
“You were seventy-four,” she said. “I thought, she’s seventy-four. She’s alone. She’s planting tomatoes. What am I going to do? Walk up and say, hi, I’m your daughter, a doctor stole your eggs in 1983? I thought it would kill you.”
“So I didn’t,” she said. “I went home. I put the letter back in the shoebox. I tried to forget about it.”
She looked down at Grace. At my shoulder. Crying softly now.
“And then yesterday,” Rebecca said, “the clinic called me.”
“Dr. Moreau called me,” Rebecca said.
I stared at her.
“Lisa Moreau?”
“She’s the director,” Rebecca said. “She remembered my call. In February. She’d written it down. She’d thought about it for months, she said.”
Rebecca took a breath.
“When you came in last year,” she said, “to start using your eggs. They pulled your old file. From 1983. Out of storage. The paper one. And Dr. Moreau read it.”
“And?”
“And the retrieval record said fourteen,” Rebecca said. “Not eight. Fourteen. Dr. Halvorsen wrote eight on everything else. Every form. Every bill. Every storage record. But on the actual lab sheet, from the actual retrieval, from the morning of November fifteenth, the embryologist had written fourteen. In pencil. In the corner.”
She looked at me.
“Dr. Halvorsen missed it,” she said. “When he destroyed the other records. He missed one number. In pencil. In the corner of a lab sheet.”
“Dr. Moreau didn’t know what it meant,” Rebecca said. “At first. She thought it was a mistake. Then she found my phone call. In her notes. From February. A woman named Rebecca Thorne. Born 1984. IVF at this clinic. Looking for a Margaret A. Ellison.”
She swallowed.
“She put it together,” Rebecca said. “She told me she sat in her office for an hour after she figured it out. She said she felt sick.”
“Why didn’t she tell me?” I said. “Last year. When she figured it out. Before we started. Before Grace.”
“She didn’t figure it out until last month,” Rebecca said. “She told me. She said she was going through the old files for a state audit. She said she found the lab sheet in May. You were already eight months along. She said she didn’t know what to do. She called the clinic’s lawyers.”
Rebecca looked at me.
“She said she decided to wait,” Rebecca said. “Until the baby was born. Until you were home. Safe. She said she didn’t want to put that on you. Not while you were waiting.”
She touched the envelope.
“She called me yesterday morning,” Rebecca said. “She said, ‘Your mother’s daughter was born on Monday. Her name is Grace. I think it’s time.’”
Your mother’s daughter.
I sat down.
Hard. In the kitchen chair.
Grace was crying in earnest now. Big, hungry, newborn cries.
I couldn’t move.
I just sat there with my daughter crying on my shoulder, staring at my other daughter across the kitchen table.
Rebecca stood up.
“Can I—” she said. She stopped. She pointed at the counter. At the bottle warmer. At the can of formula. “Can I make her a bottle? You look like you’re about to fall over.”
I looked at her.
“Do you know how?”
Rebecca almost smiled.
“I have a son,” she said. “He’s twelve. I made about ten thousand of them.”
She made the bottle.
She tested it on the inside of her wrist, the way you’re supposed to. She handed it to me.
I put it in Grace’s mouth. Grace stopped crying immediately. She sucked hard. Her little fists opened and closed.
Rebecca stood there by the counter and watched.
She was crying again. Silently.
“She’s beautiful,” she said.
“Yes.”
“Her chin,” Rebecca said. “She has it too. Doesn’t she? The little dent.”
I looked down at Grace.
I hadn’t noticed.
She did. A tiny little cleft. Like a thumbprint. Right in the middle.
I need to tell you what I felt.
Because I’ve thought about it a lot since. And it wasn’t what you’d think.
It wasn’t joy.
Not right away.
It was rage.
It came up through me like boiling water. While I sat there feeding Grace. While Rebecca stood at my kitchen counter crying.
A man took six of my eggs in 1983. While I was asleep. In the next room. And gave them away.
He decided. He decided I didn’t need them. He decided somebody else deserved them more. He decided I’d never know.
And for forty-two years, I didn’t.
I paid the storage fee every January. For eight eggs. For forty-one years. Thinking eight was all I had.
I sat at this kitchen table when I was fifty-five and cried because I thought I’d never be a mother.
I took care of my own mother for nineteen years in the spare bedroom, and when she died holding my hand, I thought: that’s it. That’s the last person who’ll ever need me like that.
I lay in a hospital bed at seventy-three with my heart racing and thought: I’ve never had anybody who was mine.
And the whole time, she was out there.
Rebecca.
Fifteen minutes away. In Wethersfield.
Learning to walk. Losing her first tooth. Going to prom. Getting married. Having a son.
While I graded chemistry exams and planted tomatoes and wrote that storage check every January.
I wanted to scream.
I wanted to find Erik Halvorsen’s grave and scream at it.
I wanted to drive to the clinic and throw something through Lisa Moreau’s window.
I wanted to sit on my kitchen floor and cry until I couldn’t anymore.
But Grace was in my arms.
Drinking her bottle.
And Rebecca was standing at my counter. Crying. With my chin.
So I didn’t do any of those things.
I just sat there.
And fed my daughter.
“Did you know?” I said finally. “Your mother. Diane. Did she know where the eggs came from?”
Rebecca shook her head.
“No,” she said. “I’m sure. I’ve thought about it a lot. She thought it was a donor. An angel. She talked about you. Well. Not you. The angel. Every year on my birthday. She’d say a little prayer at dinner. ‘Thank you to the woman who gave us Rebecca.’”
Her voice cracked.
“Every single birthday,” she said. “Forty-two years. She thanked you. She just didn’t know your name.”
I closed my eyes.
“And your father?”
“Dad died in 2016,” Rebecca said. “Heart attack. He didn’t know either. I’m sure of it. He was a high school band director. In Newington. He couldn’t keep a secret to save his life. He told me what I was getting for Christmas every year by Thanksgiving.”
I almost laughed.
“He was a good man,” Rebecca said. “They were both good. They were good parents. I had a good childhood. I want you to know that.”
She looked at me.
“I’m not here because I had a bad life,” she said. “I’m not here because I need something. I had a mother. A good one. She died in January. I miss her so much I can’t breathe some days.”
She wiped her face.
“I’m here,” she said, “because I read that letter and realized somebody had been robbed. And it wasn’t me.”
She left an hour later.
She wrote her phone number on the back of the envelope. And her address. In West Hartford. Twelve minutes from my house.
“I’m not going to bother you,” she said at the door. “I promise. You don’t have to call. I know you’ve got—”
She looked at Grace, asleep in my arms.
“I know you’ve got enough,” she said. “I just wanted you to know. That I exist. That you have—”
She stopped.
She didn’t finish the sentence.
“Rebecca,” I said.
She turned around on the front step.
“Your son,” I said. “What’s his name?”
She looked at me for a long time.
“Owen,” she said. “His name is Owen.”
I closed the door.
I stood in my front hall with my back against it.
I looked at the photograph on the wall. Thomas and me on the carousel. 1981. Laughing.
And I slid down the door until I was sitting on the floor.
With Grace asleep in my arms.
And I cried for a long, long time.
I didn’t call her for nine days.
I couldn’t.
I’d pick up the phone. I’d look at the number on the back of the envelope. And I’d put it down.
Joan came over on the third day. I told her.
She sat on my couch with her mouth open.
“Margaret,” she said. “Are you sure?”
“She has my chin, Joanie.”
“Lots of people have that chin.”
“She has Mother’s chin,” I said. “And so does Grace.”
Joan didn’t say anything for a long time.
“What are you going to do?” she said finally.
“I don’t know.”
“Are you going to sue?”
“Sue who? Halvorsen’s dead.”
“The clinic,” Joan said. “They’re responsible. It was their doctor. Their records. Their—”
“Lisa Moreau is the one who found it,” I said. “She’s the one who called Rebecca. She could have buried it. She found one number, in pencil, in the corner of a lab sheet, and she could have thrown it away and nobody would ever have known.”
Joan was quiet.
“She didn’t,” I said.
On the fourth day, Lisa Moreau called me.
“Margaret,” she said. “I’m so sorry. I don’t even know how to begin.”
“Rebecca came to my house,” I said.
“I know. She called me afterward.”
“Why didn’t you tell me first?” I said. “Why did you call her? Why did she have to be the one?”
Lisa was quiet for a long moment.
“Because she was the one who’d been looking,” she said. “Since February. She was the one who called. She had the letter. It was addressed to you. It was meant to come to you through her. That’s how Halvorsen set it up. That’s what he wrote.”
She took a breath.
“And because,” she said, “I didn’t think it was my place to tell you that you had a daughter. I thought she should be the one.”
“The clinic’s lawyers want to talk to you,” Lisa said. “There’s going to be an investigation. The state medical board. We’ve already reported it.”
“Okay.”
“They want to offer you a settlement,” Lisa said. “For what was done. It’s going to be substantial.”
I didn’t say anything.
“Margaret,” Lisa said. “I want you to know something. Off the record. Not as the director. As a doctor.”
“What?”
“I’ve been doing this for twenty-six years,” she said. “I’ve never seen anything like what Halvorsen did. Never. It’s the worst thing I’ve ever seen in this field. It’s a violation. Of you. Of your body. Of your choices.”
She was quiet for a moment.
“But I’ve also never seen anything like what happened afterward,” she said. “Seven eggs didn’t make it. One loss. And the eighth one did. Forty-one years in a freezer. And it did.”
She paused.
“You were already a mother,” she said. “The whole time. And you didn’t know. And then you became one again. Against every single odd. Twice.”
On the ninth day, I called Rebecca.
She picked up on the first ring.
“Margaret?”
“Can you come over?” I said. “On Saturday? And bring Owen?”
She didn’t say anything for a long time.
“Are you sure?” she said.
“No,” I said. “But come anyway.”
They came on Saturday at two o’clock.
Rebecca in jeans and a gray sweater. Owen next to her.
He was twelve. Tall for his age. Skinny. All elbows and knees. Dark hair that needed cutting. Glasses. A Red Sox T-shirt.
He stood on my front step and looked up at me.
“Hi,” he said.
“Hi, Owen.”
He looked at me for a long time. At my face.
“You have Mom’s chin,” he said.
I let them in.
Owen went straight to the photograph in the front hall. Thomas and me on the carousel.
“Is that you?” he said.
“Yes.”
“Who’s the guy?”
“His name was Thomas,” I said. “I was going to marry him.”
“What happened?”
I looked at Rebecca. She shook her head slightly. Like, you don’t have to.
“He died,” I said. “Skiing. In 1982.”
Owen looked at the picture for a long time.
“That’s really sad,” he said.
“It was.”
“Is that why you froze your eggs?” Owen said. “Mom told me. In the car.”
I looked at Rebecca. She was turning red.
“Owen,” she said.
“It’s okay,” I said. “Yes. That’s partly why.”
Owen nodded slowly.
“So if he didn’t die,” Owen said, “you would have just had kids normal. And then that doctor wouldn’t have stolen any. And then Mom wouldn’t exist.”
He looked at his mother.
“And neither would I,” he said.
Nobody said anything.
Owen looked back at the picture.
“That’s really weird,” he said.
“It is really weird,” I said.
Grace was asleep in her bassinet in the living room.
Owen walked over and looked down at her for a long time.
“She’s so small,” he said.
“She’s thirteen days old.”
“Is she my aunt?”
I opened my mouth. I closed it.
I looked at Rebecca.
Rebecca was looking at me too. She didn’t know either.
“I think,” I said slowly, “she’s your mom’s sister. Half-sister. Genetically.”
“So she’s my aunt,” Owen said. “A baby aunt.”
He thought about that.
“That’s so weird,” he said again. “I’m her nephew. And I’m twelve. And she’s a baby.”
He looked up at me.
“And you’re my grandma,” he said.
I sat down on the couch.
I hadn’t planned to. My legs just stopped working.
My grandma.
Seventy-five years old. A mother for thirteen days.
And a grandmother.
For twelve years.
Rebecca sat down on the other end of the couch.
Not close. But not far.
We sat there. Both of us. Looking at Owen looking at Grace in the bassinet.
“Can I hold her?” Owen said.
I looked at Rebecca.
“He’s good with babies,” Rebecca said. “He held his cousin’s twins when they were born. He’s careful.”
“Sit down in that chair,” I said to Owen. “The rocking chair. And make your arms like a cradle.”
Owen sat. He made his arms like a cradle. Very seriously.
I picked up Grace. She stirred. She didn’t wake up.
I put her in Owen’s arms.
He held her.
He didn’t say anything for a long time.
Then he looked down at her.
“Hi,” he whispered. “I’m Owen. I’m your nephew. I know that’s weird.”
Grace opened her eyes.
Owen froze.
“She’s looking at me,” he whispered.
“She can’t really see yet,” I said. “Not well. Just shapes.”
“She’s looking at me,” Owen said again.
He looked up at me. Then at his mother.
“She has the chin,” he said. “Mom. Look. She has the chin.”
Rebecca started crying.
Right there on my couch. With her face in her hands.
I didn’t know what to do.
So I moved over. To her end of the couch.
And I put my hand on her back.
She didn’t flinch.
She leaned into it.
Just a little.
They came back the next Saturday.
And the one after that.
It was hard.
I’m not going to pretend it wasn’t.
There were long silences. Times when neither of us knew what to say. Times when I’d look at her and feel that rage come up again. Not at her. At Halvorsen. At what he took. At forty-two years of birthdays and first days of school and scraped knees that I’d never get back.
There were times she looked at me like she didn’t know who I was.
Because she didn’t.
She’d had a mother. A good one. Diane Thorne. Who thanked the angel every birthday. Who died in January.
I wasn’t her mother.
Not really.
I was a stranger with her chin.
“I don’t know what to call you,” Rebecca said. The third Saturday. We were sitting on my back porch. Owen was in the living room watching a Red Sox game. Grace was asleep in her bassinet next to us.
“Margaret’s fine.”
“It feels weird.”
“Everything about this is weird.”
She almost laughed.
“Mom,” she said. Slowly. Testing it. “I can’t call you that. I’m sorry. I called somebody else that for forty-two years. She died six months ago. I can’t.”
“I’m not asking you to,” I said.
“I know you’re not,” Rebecca said. “I just—I want you to know why.”
“I know why,” I said.
We sat there for a while.
“Can I ask you something?” Rebecca said.
“Of course.”
“Are you angry?” she said. “At me? For existing?”
I turned and looked at her.
“No,” I said. “God, no. Rebecca. No.”
“Because I would be,” she said. “If I were you. I’d look at me and think, she got everything. The childhood. The birthdays. The life. She got all of it. And I got eight eggs in a freezer and a storage bill every January.”
She looked at me.
“I’d be so angry,” she said.
I looked out at my backyard.
At the tomato plants I’d put in back in April. Before Grace. Before Rebecca.
“I’m angry,” I said finally. “I’m so angry I can’t sleep some nights. But not at you.”
I looked at her.
“At him,” I said. “At Halvorsen. At a man who decided he knew better than me. Who decided what my body was for. Who decided I’d never use more than eight. Who decided I didn’t need to know.”
I took a breath.
“He took forty-two years from me,” I said. “And from you. And from Diane, too, I think. She never got to know the angel’s name. She never got to say thank you to my face. And I never got to tell her she raised a good daughter.”
Rebecca put her hand over her mouth.
“I’m angry,” I said. “But not at you. Never at you. You didn’t take anything.”
I looked at her.
“You’re the only good thing he ever did,” I said. “And he didn’t even do it on purpose.”
In August, I got sick.
It was a Tuesday. Grace was two months old. I’d been up with her at two in the morning and four in the morning and six.
At seven-thirty, I was standing in the kitchen making a bottle.
And my heart started racing.
Like it did two years ago, watching Jeopardy. Fast and hard and uneven. Fluttering in my chest like a bird trapped in a box.
I put the bottle down.
I put my hand on the counter.
The room started to tilt.
Grace was in her bassinet in the living room. Crying.
I couldn’t get to her.
I couldn’t walk.
I slid down to the kitchen floor. I sat there with my back against the cabinet and my hand pressed to my chest.
Grace was screaming now.
I couldn’t get to her.
My phone was on the counter. Above my head.
I reached up. I knocked it down. It hit the floor next to me.
I picked it up. My hands were shaking. I couldn’t see the screen right.
I didn’t call 911.
I don’t know why.
I called the last number I’d called.
“Margaret?” Rebecca said. “Is everything—”
“My heart,” I said. “Grace. I can’t get to her. Rebecca. I can’t get to her.”
“I’m coming,” Rebecca said. “I’m coming. Hang up. Call 911. Right now. I’m coming.”
She was there in nine minutes.
Before the ambulance.
She drove twelve minutes in nine. I found out later she ran two red lights on Farmington Avenue.
She came through my front door at a run. I’d never locked it. I never do.
She found me on the kitchen floor. She knelt down. She put her hand on my face.
“Margaret. Margaret. Look at me.”
“Grace,” I said.
“I’ve got her,” Rebecca said. “I’ve got her. The ambulance is right behind me. I can hear it. I’ve got Grace.”
She went into the living room. I heard her pick up Grace. I heard Grace stop screaming. I heard Rebecca saying, “Shh. Shh, baby. Shh. I’ve got you. Mommy’s okay. Mommy’s going to be okay.”
Mommy.
She said Mommy.
They took me to Hartford Hospital.
The same hospital. The same floor where I’d held Grace for the first time ten weeks earlier.
Atrial fibrillation again. Worse this time. My heart rate was a hundred and eighty-two when the paramedics got there.
They gave me medicine. It didn’t work. They had to shock my heart again. Cardioversion.
I woke up in a hospital bed at four in the afternoon.
Rebecca was sitting next to the bed.
With Grace asleep on her chest.
“Hey,” Rebecca said.
“Hey.”
“You scared the hell out of me,” she said.
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry.”
She shifted Grace on her shoulder.
“Joan’s on her way,” Rebecca said. “She had to get back from her granddaughter’s swim meet in Avon. She’ll be here in an hour.”
“You stayed,” I said.
“Of course I stayed.”
“With Grace.”
“Of course with Grace,” Rebecca said. “Who else was going to take her?”
I looked at her.
At my daughter. Forty-two years old. With my chin.
Holding my other daughter. Ten weeks old. With my chin.
“Rebecca,” I said.
“Yeah?”
“When I die,” I said, “and I will, sooner than most people—”
“Margaret, don’t—”
“Let me say it,” I said. “Please. I need to say it.”
She stopped.
“When I die,” I said, “Grace goes to Joan. That’s what the papers say. I signed them a year ago. Before I knew.”
I looked at her.
“Joan is seventy,” I said. “She has grandchildren in Avon and a husband with a bad hip and she said yes because she loves me. But she didn’t want to. I could tell.”
Rebecca didn’t say anything.
“I lay in a hospital bed two years ago,” I said, “and the only question anybody could ask me was, who’s going to raise her? Who’s going to raise that baby when you’re gone? And I didn’t have a good answer. I had Joan. That’s all I had.”
I took a breath.
“I’m not asking you,” I said. “I want to be really clear. I am not asking you to do that. You have Owen. You have your own life. You didn’t ask for any of this. Not one bit of it.”
Rebecca was crying.
“But I wanted you to know,” I said, “that I’ve thought about it. And if you ever wanted. Someday. To be in those papers. I’d want it to be you.”
Rebecca didn’t say anything for a long time.
She looked down at Grace. Asleep on her chest.
She touched Grace’s chin. The little dent.
“She’s my sister,” Rebecca said.
“Yes.”
“I grew up an only child,” Rebecca said. “My whole life. Mom and Dad wanted more. They tried. It didn’t work. I always wanted a sister. I used to pretend. When I was little. I had an imaginary sister named Molly. Mom used to set a place for her at dinner.”
She laughed a little. Through the tears.
“I’m forty-two,” she said. “And I just got a sister.”
She looked at me.
“You don’t have to ask,” she said. “I’ll do it.”
“Rebecca,” I said. “You need to think about it. Talk to your husband—”
“I’m divorced,” Rebecca said. “Six years. It’s just me and Owen.”
“Then talk to Owen.”
“I already did,” Rebecca said.
I stared at her.
“In the car,” she said. “On the way over here. In the ambulance. After. Owen called me. He was scared. He asked if you were going to die. I said I didn’t know.”
She swallowed.
“And he said, ‘Mom, if Grandma Margaret dies, can Grace come live with us?’”
I put my hand over my eyes.
“He’s twelve,” Rebecca said. “He’s twelve years old. And that’s what he asked. Not what’s going to happen to us. Not what about me. ‘Can Grace come live with us.’”
She wiped her face with her free hand.
“So I already talked to Owen,” she said. “We already decided.”
I changed the papers in September.
At the lawyer’s office in Farmington. The same lawyer who’d drawn up the first ones. Mr. Pelletier. Seventy, with a bow tie.
He looked at the new names. He looked at me.
“Rebecca Thorne,” he said. “Who is she?”
I looked at Rebecca. Sitting in the chair next to me. With Grace on her lap.
“My daughter,” I said.
Mr. Pelletier looked at me over his glasses.
“Miss Ellison,” he said. “I’ve been your lawyer for twenty years. You’ve never once mentioned a daughter.”
“I just found out,” I said.
He looked at Rebecca. At her chin. At my chin.
He looked at Grace. At her chin.
He took his glasses off.
“I’m not going to ask,” he said.
“Thank you,” I said.
Joan was there too. She signed something saying she agreed. That she was stepping aside as primary guardian. That she’d be the backup.
When she was done, she put the pen down.
She looked at Rebecca for a long time.
“I’m her aunt,” Joan said. “Grace’s. And yours, I guess.”
“I guess,” Rebecca said.
Joan looked at her a moment longer.
“You have our mother’s chin,” she said.
“So I keep hearing.”
Joan reached across the table.
She took Rebecca’s hand.
“Welcome to the family,” she said. “We’re all crazy. Just so you know.”
I settled with the clinic in November.
I’m not going to say how much. It doesn’t matter.
I put all of it in two trusts. One for Grace. One for Owen.
Rebecca didn’t want me to put anything in for Owen.
“He’s not—” she started.
“He’s my grandson,” I said. “He’s the first person who called me Grandma.”
She didn’t argue after that.
Erik Halvorsen’s medical license was posthumously revoked by the state medical board in December.
It doesn’t mean anything. He’s been dead for fourteen years.
But it’s on the record now.
What he did. In writing. With his name on it.
The state launched an investigation. They’re looking at every egg retrieval Halvorsen did between 1981 and 1998. Hundreds of them.
They’ve already found three more.
Three more women who had more eggs taken than they were told. Three more children out there. Grown now. Who don’t know.
Lisa Moreau is calling them. One at a time.
She called me after the first one.
“She’s sixty-eight,” Lisa said. “In Vermont. She had two eggs taken in 1986. She had a son, a few years later. Her own. Naturally. She’s a grandmother now.”
“Did you tell her?”
“I told her,” Lisa said. “She cried for an hour.”
“Is there a child?”
“There’s a child,” Lisa said. “A man. He’s thirty-eight. He lives in Ohio. We’re trying to find him.”
She was quiet for a moment.
“Margaret,” she said. “I want to ask you something.”
“Okay.”
“Would you talk to her?” Lisa said. “The woman in Vermont. She’s terrified. She doesn’t know what to do. She asked me if anybody else had been through this.”
I looked at Grace. Asleep in her bassinet.
“Give her my number,” I said.
Grace turned one in June.
We had a party in my backyard on Fern Street.
Joan came. With her husband and her grandchildren from Avon. Jolene came, our surrogate, with Ray and their three kids. Lisa Moreau came, with a stuffed bear and a card.
The woman from Vermont came. Her name is Ruth. She drove down with her husband. She’s been calling me every Sunday since December.
Her son from Ohio didn’t come. Not yet. They’ve met once. At a Panera in Erie, Pennsylvania. Halfway. Ruth said it went well. Ruth said he has her chin.
And Rebecca came.
And Owen.
Owen made a sign. Hand-lettered. In marker. Taped to my back fence.
HAPPY 1ST BIRTHDAY AUNT GRACE
Everybody laughed when they saw it.
“I’m her nephew,” Owen explained to Jolene’s kids. Very seriously. “I’m thirteen and she’s one. It’s a long story.”
“How is that possible?” Jolene’s middle kid said.
Owen thought about it.
“Science,” he said.
Grace sat in her high chair at the picnic table in a yellow party dress. Joan made it. With a little white collar.
Rebecca brought the cake. A small one. Vanilla with pink frosting. One candle.
We sang.
Grace looked at the candle. At all of us. At the faces around the table.
At my face. Seventy-six now.
At Rebecca’s face. Forty-three.
At Owen’s face. Thirteen.
Three chins. All the same.
She stuck her whole hand in the cake.
Everybody cheered.
Later, after everybody had gone home, Rebecca and I sat on the back porch.
Grace was asleep in her crib upstairs. In the green room with the clouds on the ceiling. Owen was in the living room playing a video game.
It was warm. The tomato plants were growing up the fence. Fireflies were starting to come out in the yard.
We didn’t say anything for a long time.
“Margaret,” Rebecca said finally.
“Hmm?”
“I found something,” she said. “In Mom’s things. Diane’s. Last week. In the attic. I’d missed it before.”
She reached into her purse.
She took out a little book. Small. Leather. Worn soft at the corners. A journal.
“She kept a journal,” Rebecca said. “When she was pregnant with me. I didn’t know.”
She opened it to a page. She handed it to me.
It was handwriting I’d never seen. Round. Loopy. A woman’s.
October 3, 1984.
Rebecca is two weeks old today. She’s perfect. She has a little dent in her chin. Like a thumbprint. Bill doesn’t have one. I don’t have one.
It must come from the angel.
I wonder who she is. I wonder if she has the dent too. I wonder if she knows. I wonder if she’s somewhere right now, thinking about the eggs she gave, wondering what happened to them.
I hope she knows.
I hope someday I can tell her. Thank you. She made me a mother. She made us a family.
If I ever meet her, I’m going to show her Rebecca’s chin. And I’m going to say, look. Look what you did.
I closed the journal.
I couldn’t see anymore.
Rebecca reached over. She took my hand.
She didn’t say anything.
“She never got to meet you,” Rebecca said after a while. “That’s the part that gets me. She would’ve loved you. She would’ve sat right here on this porch and cried and hugged you and made you a lasagna.”
“I would’ve liked that,” I said.
“She thanked you every birthday,” Rebecca said. “For forty-two years. And you were fifteen minutes away the whole time.”
I looked at the fireflies in my backyard.
“I wish I could tell her,” I said. “That she did a good job. With you.”
Rebecca was quiet.
“You just did,” she said.
That night, after Rebecca and Owen went home, I went upstairs.
I stood in the doorway of the green room.
Grace was asleep in her crib. On her back. Arms over her head. Her little mouth open. The tiny dent in her chin.
The clouds on the ceiling glowed faintly in the dark. Joan had painted them with glow-in-the-dark paint, last fall. She said every baby should have stars, but clouds were more practical.
I walked over to the crib.
I looked down at my daughter.
Seventy-six years old. A mother for one year.
And for forty-three.
I thought about the eight eggs.
Seven didn’t make it. One did.
I thought about the six.
Six that I never knew about. That a man took while I was sleeping. That he gave away.
One of them made it too.
For forty-two years, I thought I had nobody who was mine.
I sat at my kitchen table at fifty-five and cried. I paid the storage fee every January. I lay in a hospital bed at seventy-three with my heart racing and thought, I’ve never had anybody who was mine.
I was wrong.
I had somebody the whole time.
I just didn’t know her name.
I reached down into the crib.
I touched Grace’s chin. Very gently. With one finger. The little dent.
She didn’t wake up.
She just sighed. And turned her head a little toward my hand.
Downstairs, on the kitchen table, there was a card. Rebecca left it there before she went home. I found it after.
A birthday card. For Grace. With a cartoon giraffe on the front.
Inside, Rebecca had written:
To my little sister, Grace —
Happy first birthday. I’ve been waiting for you for forty-two years. I just didn’t know it.
Love, Becca
And under that, in different handwriting, a little smaller:
And to my mother, Margaret —
Thank you. Look what you did.
— R.